Automation & Robotics
Before You Automate: Define the Problem First

Define the problem, not the machine
Before requesting automation proposals, describe what is going wrong, where it happens and how it affects production. “We need a robot” names a solution. “Inconsistent product positioning causes downstream stops” gives engineers a problem to investigate.
Observe operators, maintenance staff and supervisors during normal running, start-up, cleaning, changeovers and fault recovery. Compare representative products and shifts; a steady demonstration rarely exposes difficult conditions.
Find the cause before investing
Record cycle times, waiting, rejects, interventions and recurring faults using consistent definitions. Separate planned downtime from breakdowns and minor stops. Test operator observations against production records.
Check materials, tooling, settings, utilities and work methods. Where practical, vary one factor at a time. Correct maintenance and process-control issues before automating them.
Illustrative example: a beverage line
Imagine bottles repeatedly tipping at a conveyor transfer before labeling. A faster handling system might appear attractive, but the cause could be mismatched conveyor speeds, unsuitable guides or unstable bottle presentation.
Observe different bottle formats and start-stop conditions, inspect the transfer and test adjustments safely. Confirm the cause before specifying automation. This is an illustrative scenario, not a customer case study.
Check the whole production system
Identify what limits acceptable finished output. Speeding up a station that waits for material may add little production.
Map upstream supply, downstream capacity, buffers, staffing and material movement. Check space, access, floor loading, utilities and control interfaces. Account for product variability, human intervention and safe fault clearance.
Set measurable acceptance criteria
Establish a baseline, then define output, quality, changeover, ergonomic and reliability requirements under stated operating conditions. Measure acceptable finished units over a defined period, not just maximum machine speed.
Specify product range, staffing and permitted interruptions. Treat safety and regulatory compliance as essential requirements, never trade-offs for speed.
Compare options and prepare a brief
Consider layout, tooling, maintenance and standard-work improvements alongside automation. Compare programming, cleaning, maintenance, training, spare parts and lifecycle costs. Include installation disruption and the skills needed to sustain the system. A stable manual process with targeted automation may be more suitable than automating every step.
Test representative products and difficult operating cases against agreed acceptance criteria. Assign responsibility for integration, commissioning, documentation and recovery procedures. A trial should resolve uncertainty, not merely demonstrate motion.
Capture verified problems, baseline performance, product characteristics, interfaces and objectives in one brief. Separate mandatory requirements from preferences and flag untested assumptions. Agree who supplies samples, utilities, data and trained operators for acceptance testing. Agree how results will be checked during acceptance and after installation. Give providers the same requirements so proposals can be compared on technical fit, implementation risk and ongoing operating needs.
Key Takeaways
Define and verify the problem before selecting equipment.
Address root causes and the line’s actual constraint.
Compare alternatives using measurable criteria and lifecycle requirements.
Facing an industrial challenge? Share your requirements with IGA and explore relevant expertise and technology options.
Back to IGA Academy
LET’S MOVE INDUSTRY FORWARD
Industrial challenges. Addressed by Experts.
Tell us what your operation needs to achieve.
Describe your requirements, objectives and main constraints. Free initial review. No purchasing commitment.
IGA / Technical Advisory · Technology Sourcing · Industrial Knowledge
© 2026 IGA. All rights reserved.